An Extremely Goofy Movie

Disney released yet another direct-to-video sequel in 2000, this time, to A Goofy Movie. Starring everyone from the original film, plus Jeff Bennett, Vicki Lewis, Brad Garrett, and Bebe Neuwirth, An Extremely Goofy Movie is the only Disney direct-to-video sequel to rate higher than its predecessor on Rotten Tomatoes until 2006.

In the film, Max heads to college and looks to compete in the College X-Games. However, Goofy is fired from his job and must go back to college to finish his degree. He arrives at Max’s school, joins a rival team and befriends the librarian, who shares his love of 1970s nostalgia. Meanwhile, PJ falls in love with a poet.

As Rotten Tomatoes notes, this film is actually considerably better than its predecessor. The background animations don’t freeze like they did and the subject is much more interesting. It makes sense to have the film be centered on sports, as the X Games were hitting their peak in popularity at the time.

While it seems Max took a step backwards in characterization, it must be realized that he was excited to finally start his own life, but Goofy bounced back into it and started messing everything up. And Goofy was dealing with empty nest syndrome, of course he would want to come to the same school Max was in. Unlike the first film, the two do communicate, but this time it just leads to a falling out which is repaired in the eleventh hour.

Giving Goofy a love interest is actually a great idea, mainly because it gives him someone other than Max to have intimate interactions with. Besides, him and Sylvia tearing it up Disco Style is perfect. Same with PJ. Having him finally express himself and break away from being an neurotic mess helps to develop his character and make him finally be who he was meant to be.

The music was great as well, but I have a predisposition to music from the 70s. 

One thing though, there’s the suspicious absence of Roxanne. With Max doing everything he could to be with her in the first film, it seems odd that she wouldn’t show up. She wasn’t even mentioned.

#28

Mickey's Once Upon a Christmas

Well, we’re back to Disney. And the category.

Disney put out a direct to video Christmas movie November 9, 1999. Mickey’s Once Upon a Christmas was a package film with three segments. Starring Wayne Allwine, Tony Anselmo, Jeff Bennett, Alan Young, Jim Cummings, Bill Farmer and Frank Welker, it was narrated by Kelsey Grammer.

The first segment, “Stuck on Christmas” puts Huey, Dewey and Louie in a Groundhog Day loop on Christmas day. And they soon get tired of it.

“A Very Goofy Christmas” has Max question Santa’s existence and Goofy is determined to keep his faith alive.

The final segment, “Mickey and Minnie’s Gift of the Magi” centers on the duo planning to give each other great gifts, but can’t because of circumstances. They then sacrifice their prized possessions for the gifts.

When you have an Aesop to teach, there’s one of two ways to do it. You can either present it in a subtle manner or whack the viewer over the head with a sledgehammer. And while these three segments are good, all their lessons come about the latter way.

There’s not much I can say on these other than that, except that the second segment can actually be very relatable. Especially for someone who dealt with the subject matter at that age.

#40

A Goofy Movie

Goof Troop was a pretty popular series, causing Disney to produce a theatrical sequel after it ended. Starring Bill Farmer, Jason Marsden, Rob Paulsen, Pauly Shore and Pat Buttram, A Goofy Movie was released April 7, 1995. It ended up being dedicated to Buttram, who died during production.

“I2I” was also one of the first songs I ever put on my iPod.

Goofy (Farmer) is a single father to the teenage Max (Marsden), who gets into trouble on the last day of school. Goofy becomes worried that he hasn’t been spending enough time with Max and decides to take him on a road trip However, Max is more worried about impressing Roxanne (Kellie Martin), a girl at his school. The road trip will mean he’ll have to miss a date with her and he claims it’s because Goofy is taking him to a concert in Los Angeles, where he will appear on stage with the pop sensation, Powerline (Tevin Campbell).

Where Ducktales the Movie felt like a glorified series finale, A Goofy Movie succeeded in actually feeling like a theatrical continuation of the series. It’s set quite a bit after the series too and succeeds in aging Max and PJ well.

Max has grown into a realistic teenager, obsessed with current pop culture and embarrassed at Goofy. Sure he was embarrassed in the series, but here, he actually loathes Goofy at times. And for good reason. Goofy just won’t take the time to shut up and listen. But at the same time, he’s trying to be a good father by doing what he thinks is best for his son. And you can’t really blame him, thanks to Principal Mazur blowing Max’s stunt completely out of proportion, going from harmless interruption and musical interlude to gang fight causing a riot, Goofy thought he was actually doing Max some good. Both sides are actually to blame for the plot. Goofy won’t get Max’s side of the story and Max is too busy brooding after heading out on the open road to tell his father. It’s interesting to see how both characters develop. By the time “Nobody Else But You” is sung, they’ve come to really understand where the other is coming from. And then Goofy makes Max’s lie a reality.

The other characters are pretty flat and are the same from how they were in the series. Pete’s still a dominating father and PJ is still a neurotic twit. There are also characters who don’t appear in the series. Bobby is your stereotypical 90s surfer/stoner. But since he’s voiced by everyone’s favorite washed up 90s stereotypical surfer/stoner actor (Pauly Shore), it’s pulled off moderately well. Though, there’s not much to say for Roxanne, she barely shows up, but it’s easy to see why Max likes her. The best side character is probably Principal Mazur. Because he has no idea what students actually like or want to do and thinks that popular music is cause for believing the student is in a gang and will head for the electric chair. On the other hand, where are Peg and Pistol? There’s a popular theory that she divorced him and took Pistol between series and movie, but there needs to be an actual explanation for their absence.

Also, a lot of background characters have a tendency to freeze while there’s still action going onscreen. Seriously. In the diner, people stop eating, the cook stops cooking and the waitress just stands there. I’ve seen television shows that do it better. But it’s only in a few areas and, while distracting, doesn’t really harm the film.

#25

Initial Reaction: A Goofy Movie

As a sequel to the Goof Troop series, this film is quite good. Max has a different VA, but that just shows he's grown up. And further demonstrates that Goofy is oblivious to what's going on with his son.

Max has a very distinct personality in this film, different than he was in the series and it helps to further that distance. And once Goofy finally shuts up and listens, the two bonding over song down a river is actually pretty good.

Yeah, all the songs are good too.

But one obvious flaw is the background animation. You can tell they were focusing more on Pocahontas than this film. It's not badly drawn, but background characters noticeably freeze while there's still action going onscreen. It's kind of distracting.

Right now, I want to put it at #25.